top of page

VCD Outcome 1: 
Design process: refining and resolving design concepts

How do designers resolve design problems?

In this area of study, we will:

  • reflect critically on feedback received in Unit 3, Outcome 3 as you evaluate, select and evolve design ideas into concepts for further refinement and testing.

In doing so, we will: 

  • explore the Deliver phase of the VCD design process.

  • engage in an iterative cycle as you rework ideas, revisit research and review the client’s needs.

  • manipulate the design elements and principles in response to the brief and develop expertise in a range of appropriate manual and digital methods, materials and media.

  • Development and documentation drawings, together with mock-ups, models and low-fidelity prototypes, may be used to assist with visualising, testing and resolving design concepts.

During this process, we will:

  • move from divergent to convergent thinking, drawing on conceptions of good design when synthesising ideas and using annotations to evaluate their potential.

  • The refinement of design concepts for each communication need continues as two separate design processes, with you ensuring that these are distinct from one another in purpose and presentation format. 

You will:

  • resolve selected design concepts and devise a pitch of one concept for each communication need to communicate your design thinking and decision making to an audience or user.

  • explain the reasons for your selection and use of particular materials, media and methods, design elements and principles, and formats for presentation.

  • consider responses to their pitch and further refine each selected concept, in preparation for the presentation of final design solutions.

​(Source: VCD Study design p46 https://www.vcaa.vic.edu.au/Documents/vce/visualcomm/2024VisualCommunicationDesignSD.docx)

​

Outcome 1 

On completion of this unit you should be able to:

  • refine and resolve distinct design concepts for each communication need,

  • and devise and deliver a pitch to communicate concepts to an audience or users,

  • evaluating the extent to which these meet the requirements of the brief.

To achieve this outcome the student will draw on key knowledge and key skills outlined in Area of Study 1.

​

Key Knowledge:

  • the Deliver phase of the VCD design process

  • the role of the brief and convergent thinking when refining and resolving design concepts

  • features and functions of the design elements and principles used to create and resolve design concepts

  • manual and digital methods, media, materials and conventions used to create design concepts 

  • methods and techniques used to evaluate, test and resolve design concepts

  • techniques used to deliver a pitch to present and explain design concepts

  • the extent to which design concepts meet the requirements of the brief

  • conceptions of good design

  • legal and ethical obligations relevant to the designer’s work

  • appropriate design terminology.

​​​

Key Skills

  • apply the Deliver phase of the VCD design process

  • select and apply a range of manual and digital methods, materials, media and conventions, together with the design elements and principles to resolve design concepts 

  • use convergent thinking strategies to refine and resolve design concepts

  • test and evaluate the suitability and quality of refined design concepts, drawing on the requirements of the brief

  • devise and deliver a pitch that supports the presentation of one design concept for each communication need

  • apply practices that fulfil the designer’s ethical and legal obligations

  • use appropriate terminology to document the refinement and resolution of design concepts.

​

​

​

Success Criteria:

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

I Can...

Outcome 1 Criterion 1-6:

Outcome 1 Criterion 7 Pitch:

 

Discussion points:

​

  • What is a pitch in VCD?

  • Where else have you heard the word 'pitch'? (For example, in ball games, music, etc.).

  • What is the purpose of the design pitch?

​

​What does the ‘pitch’ involve?

  • An evaluation of the ways that the final visual communications meet the requirements of the design brief

  • Design decisions made during the design process

  • Reasons for the selection and use of particular methods, materials, media, design elements, design principles and presentation formats

  • Draw on annotations to inform the pitch

  • Respond to questions if further clarification is required.

  • An evaluation of the ways that the final visual communications meet the requirements of the design brief

  • Design decisions made during the design process

  • Reasons for the selection and use of particular methods, materials, media, design elements, design principles and presentation formats

  • Draw on annotations to inform the pitch

  • Respond to questions if further clarification is required.

 

Sample Questions:

  • In what role did you present yourself to your client?

  • Explain who your client was and what needs he/she required to be undertaken by you?

  • Explain what research you undertook and how this informed your design concepts.

  • Explain how and why you arrived at your final concepts; what material choices were made, what media selected, what methods best suited and how did particular design elements and design principles support and enhance your concepts?

  • How did your 2 final presentations fulfil the client needs as outlined in the brief including; your response to the target audience specifications, the purpose of each presentation, the context within which it will ‘sit’ and how you respected and responded to the stated constraints and expectations?

​

​

Watch:

​

Before watching prompts:

  • Identify the focus for each slide or stage of the presentation.

  • Note how time is given to each stage.

  • Observe how each stage/slide/idea connects to the next to create flow and cohesion.

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

During Watching Discussion Points:

 

  • What are the print texts, visual representations, and oral delivery components?

  • How do they complement one another?

  • How different components organised on the slide (For example, visualisation drawings, annotations, type, etc.)?

  • What VCD-specific terminology/concepts are presented (for example, design elements and principles, methods, media, and materials)?

  • What connective words are used to make links between components?

​

After watching Discussion points:

​

  • Is the presentation clearly structured? Is it cohesive?

  • Is the presentation successful?

  • Does the presentation meet the client's demands?

  • Provide evidence for your responses to the above.

​

In table groups, discuss the following:

  • Compare your observations of the example. Use your templates to assist your discussion.

  • In your groups, decide on collective responses to the following questions:

    • What were the most successful elements of the presentation? Why?

  • What could have been modified or improved? Why?

​

(Source: https://www.education.vic.gov.au/school/teachers/teachingresources/discipline/english/literacy/Pages/visual-communication-design-putting-it-together.aspx)

​

Pitch%20Rubric_edited.jpg

Note: the following content requires adapting - it is based on the old study design - I am still working my way through. Thanks for your patience!

Outcome 2 Criterion 8-10:

bottom of page